Search our site…

Business and Property Listing 2021

New York's Iconic Agritourism Desination is Available for Purchase

The Fly Creek Cider Mill is ready to re-open with a new owner!  The Mill is a historic, water-powered, cider mill making cider the old-fashioned way on the banks of Fly Creek just minutes from the Village of Cooperstown, in Upstate New York and a member of the Cooperstown Beverage Trail.

Well-positioned as an iconic agritourism destination in a high-volume, tourism market the Mill is prepared for another 165 years of taste, tradition and history.  Continue the successful operational formula or create your own.  This facility is the perfect match for any New York Craft Beverage and/or Specialty Food Producer seeking to open a branch location or simply expand the Mill’s popular brand portfolio.  Possibilities are endless with this turnkey property.

The Mill’s operation is combination of a cider mill, farm cidery & winery, specialty food store, tourism attraction, foodservice operation, e-commerce and giftware.  

The listing includes the business, equipment, remaining inventory and two real estate parcels that include the Mill, Cider House and Goose Street Parking Lot.

Three additional and adjacent parcels are also available that include two residences, two barns and a building lot.  

Price: $1,925,000.00

Our Story

Our Business

Our Real Estate

Our Metrics

Qualified buyers who wish to view financials may purchase access for a one-time fee of $300 (refunded at closing) along with a signed condidentiality agreement.

Additional Narratives with fee include: Our Customers, Our Resources, Our COVID-19 Pivot, Our Future.

Files will be delivered through a DropBox Link with 30 day access.  Second round PPP has been recieved and is available for the new owner.

Confidentiality Agreement

Pay $300 NOW On-Line

Signed Confidentiality Agreements, offers and inquiries may be e-mailed to Vincent Gilroy, CPA | |  and Cc'ed to Bill Michaels | | with the subject line "Buyer Fly Creek". 

Include all contact information and order number from $300 purchase within e-mail.

Informative PodCast of a Mill Visit

What our visitors are saying

“I love coming to your store each time I am in Cooperstown. I have been bringing a team to play at the Dreams Park for over 15 years. My eldest son won it the second year the park was open. My youngest son also played at the park, he is now 27 yrs old. Each year I bring a new team and this Never gets old. Fly Creek Cider Mill is one of our Must go too! I tell my parents it's loveliest place for both adults and kids.”

-Liesel Campbell

“I am from California and recently visited your establishment. I cannot give you enough praise for the awesome experience, cordial employees and all-around beauty of your operation both inside and out. I just made some of your muffins from the mix I purchased-delicious.”

-Chrissie Annotti

“"...but the Apple Cider itself, really was the best! In CT we have several well known cider farms but they really do not compare to the Fly Creek Cider! Fly Creek has no sediment on the bottom, just a fresh clean apple taste. (It even freezes very well without compromising the taste.) Will be back before Thanksgiving to pick up more cider... and pie! Great tasting apple pie without the overkill of nutmeg, cinnamon, or sugar like other places."”

-TripAdvisor Reviewer
Website Development by