Pre-Order Thanksgiving Pies!

Mill-Baked Apple Pies

Perfect for your Thansgiving Table

Apple Caramel-Nut

A Farm Favorite!

Call or e-mail us today to pre-order your Holiday Pies

Pies Available: Apple ($18.99), Apple Caramel ($19.99), Fruit of the Farm (blend of Apple, Raspberries, Blackberries, Strawberries and Rhubarb)( $22.99), Strawberry Rhubarb ($22.99), Blueberry ($24.99), Pumpkin ($18.99) & Pecan ($22.99).

To order call: 607-547-9692 and press zero or E-mail: info@flycreekcidermill.com. Let us know the pick-up day.

Pick up November 20 - 22 (Closed Thanksgiving Day)

Named BEST Pie in UPSTATE New York!

Flavorful Rewards Program Information

(Closing Day for the 2023 Season will be December 17, 2023)

What our visitors are saying

“My wife and I had so much fun. We couldn't wait to get home and tell our friends. We are definitely coming back for more.”

-Gil Oliveras, Utica NY

“I drive the 3 1/2 hours to Cooperstown at least once or twice a year and ALWAYS stop by your Mill. I always bring a cooler and a list because I am always picking up for the family! Love your Fruit of the Farm, Apple and Apple Carmel Walnut pies! They are the best and your cheese is just the best!”

-Colleen Mounteer, Mt Bethel PA

“My husband and i visited your cider mill a couple weeks ago and we bought some of your "zinfandel tri tip grill marinade." We marinated some steak with it and it was absolutely delicious! It was honestly the best marinade we've ever had!”

-AOL member

Website Development by

Search form

Pre-Order Thanksgiving Pies!